Comparatively, a book critique is more like a book review. However, a book critique is generally based on judgement as opposed to general review of the contents. Notably, as a writer, you are expected to critically delve into the content of the book in question and bring out judgmental views based on elements such as accuracy, as well as the overall book quality. It is, however, notable that in order to arrive at a specific judgment, then you must primarily help the readers of your critical paper to understand the contents of the book. Ensure that the introduction is structured in a manner that a general overview of the book is provided and that the sense of your judgement is defined from the beginning. Here are tips to help you in writing a book critique:
What is The Your Overall Opinion About The Book?
It is important for you to prepare the book’s reader regarding what you will be addressing throughout the critique. This is why an overview of your judgment is needed from the beginning. In this case, you will have to spell out what you think about the book and what led to the opinion you have established. It is also important for you to clearly indicate what you expected to derive from the book. Did you nod in agreement with what the author had written? Or do you think it would be best to reach out to the author for a better publication? In other words, you should write down your reaction and explain why you think so.
The Author’s Thesis
In this case, the main focus is towards identifying the author’s thesis and explaining it in your own words. It is important to categorically inform the reader on how clearly, as well as in what context, the thesis is stated. Ideally, you need to further inform the reader on whether the thesis is adequately proven or not. You might consider it necessary to amplify your opinion with some examples. For instance, if there is any perspective missing, give the right example and what you think should be done.
Presentation of Key Points By The Author
Having read the book wholly, you need to focus on discussing the key points, as raised by the author. The main idea here is to discuss each point and the manner in which it has been presented. Note that your perspective should be based on the connection between the key points and the thesis. By extension, you need to consider the assumption behind each point, as well as how you think the points should have been presented.
Approach of Drawing Claims vs Evidence Used
Part of a book critique is to consider whether or not the author has made specific claims and effectively so. In essence, it is necessary to consider if the claims provided in the book are adequately backed with facts and logic. Has the author attributed secondary information contained in the book to the source? What do you think should be done in an instance whereby logic and assumptions conflict? It would be necessary for you to consider using examples when undertaking your evaluation on claims and evidence.
The Author’s Conclusion
At this juncture, your evaluation should be towards the author(s)’ conclusion and how clearly it is stated. It is important to consider if there is interconnection between the thesis, claims, assumptions, and the evidence provided in the book. Is the book coherent in terms of the aforementioned interconnection? Be sure to share your opinion clearly.
What is your overall thought about the book and the contents? Is your thesis or description of your overall judgment proven? Here, your conclusion should justify your opinion and judgment towards the book.